Book an Appointment
Astra Jewelers
+1-973-289-9290
Home Engagement Rings Custom Jewelry Repairs
Jewelry Repair Watch Repair All Services
Watches Guides Visit Call Us +1-973-289-9290
A jeweler measuring a ring at a workbench
Custom Jewelry Design · Upper Montclair, New Jersey

Custom jewelry,
from an idea to
the finished piece

  • A private studio, by appointmentWalk-ins are welcome too, Monday through Saturday.
  • The stone comes before the designA setting built to your exact stone.
  • See it in 3D, then wear itA printed model you wear before casting.
  • Heirloom resets and stone sourcingBring a stone you own or start from nothing.
  • Gold, platinum and white gold14k to 18k, plus rhodium replating.
Verified industry membership Proud member of Jewelers of America with JBT industry credentials.
Astra Jewelers on the Jewelers of America member directory JBT member badge
How it works
5.0 from our Google reviews Read them

Book a Design Appointment

A stone, a picture or an idea you cannot put into words yet. Every custom piece here starts with one of them. Nothing is ordered until you say so.
Preferred way to reach you required
How it works
How it works

Every custom piece starts
one of three ways

Some people arrive with a stone. Some arrive with a photograph. Most arrive with something harder to hand over, an idea. All three are normal and the studio is built to meet each one. However it starts, the sequence from there is the same. A 3D rendering, a printed model worn on your own hand and the exact price approved before anything is cast. If you are still weighing a studio against ordering from a website, the case is made honestly in our custom jewelry vs buying online guide.

01

A stone you have or one we find

Inherited, loose or sitting in a ring nobody wears. If you do not have one, gemstone sourcing starts here instead, with natural and lab grown shown side by side at matching specification. Either way the design is drawn around the stone and its exact measurements.

02

A picture you keep going back to

A screenshot folder, a saved post, a ring seen once and never forgotten. We translate it into a 3D rendering around the right stone. Changes at that stage cost nothing but a conversation.

03

An idea you cannot draw yet

The most common start of all. You describe the feeling and we put stones and options in front of you until the picture sharpens. One customer wrote that we offered ideas at exactly the point of not being able to verbalize the vision. That is the job.

Reputation

What clients say

G
Astra Jewelers View on Google

Google Reviews

Real customer feedback, see what people say about Astra Jewelers.

Amazing customer service! Highly recommended. Was able to remove our original stone and replace with a new one. They were able to source the new stone for us. And didnt stop until we found the right one. 100% amazing service. From start to finish. Communication was professional and confirmed with us, for every step of the process of what we needed to get done exactly. Affordable and willing to work with you best on budget. A+++ Now my engagement ring is exactly perfect 😍 Thank you Astra Jewelers for making my dream come to a reality.
meliphurts69
Eddie and Stephanie are the best jewelers I’ve ever worked with! They are incredibly kind, patient, and truly take the time to sit down with you, listen to your vision, and understand exactly what you’re hoping to create. You can tell they genuinely care about making pieces that you’ll love and feel confident wearing. They are always open to conversation and revisions throughout the process, and they never once made me feel silly for asking questions, changing or refining my vision, or overthinking any detail. They’re also incredibly transparent throughout the process and keep you updated along the way, which made me feel informed and comfortable from start to finish. They made me feel completely comfortable throughout the entire process. Their work is beautiful and done with so much integrity, and I always felt valued as a customer. Their process truly feels customized to each person. There are no shortcuts or band-aid fixes—they take the time to make sure everything is done the right way. It was such a pleasure working with them on our rings and a pair of earrings for my mom. Every piece came out beautifully, and I’m so grateful for the care they put into everything. I look forward to continuing to work with them for years to come!
Isabella Badagliacca
Astra Jewelers is truly a gem! Stephanie and Eddie are incredible: so professional, knowledgeable, and genuinely warm. They make you feel like family from the moment you walk in. They’ve created several custom pieces for me, and their sourcing is fabulous. They have such an amazing eye for design. Everything feels elegant, elevated, and timeless. The 3D renderings are incredibly helpful because you can really visualize the pieces and fine-tune every detail before they’re made. Throughout the entire process, Stephanie and Eddie keep you updated every step of the way, which makes the experience feel easy, exciting, and completely personal. The craftsmanship and attention to detail are exceptional. I’m completely obsessed with every piece! Everything they’ve made for me has exceeded my expectations. Astra has absolutely become my go-to jeweler, and I recommend Stephanie and Eddie wholeheartedly to anyone looking for something truly special.
Ruki Oygar
Stephanie and Eddie are amazing - I will be working with Astra Jewelers for all of my jewelry from now on! When my boyfriend and I walked in for our appointment to discuss a custom engagement ring on June 13, a kind group of customers were leaving the studio and told us how much they enjoyed their experience with Astra and we’ll be happy here. And they were 100% right. During that first appointment, Stephanie and Eddie thoughtfully listened to what I wanted for my custom ring and offered ideas when I was not able to verbalize what I envisioned. They were so welcoming, easy to talk to, and made us feel like this very important chapter in my boyfriend’s and my lives are in the best hands. Following our appointment, Stephanie kept me updated via text about the artist doing the renderings, clarified my visions even more, and helped communicate my unique, non-traditional dream “nature-inspired” engagement ring to the artist. She was responsive and helpful with my disorganized thoughts over text, and within weeks we had the most beautiful, creative, uniquely-mine ring ready for pickup. Our experience with Astra Jewelers was incredibly pleasant, calming, and stressless. Stephanie and Eddie are the best people to collaborate with, the best people to get the job done, and just overall a wonderful couple. We cannot recommend Astra Jewelers enough!
Elise Molleur
It was lovely to work with Stephanie and Eddie for a custom necklace. They are extremely knowledgeable and use high quality materials. I highly recommend Astra Jewelers!
Sarah Toosarvandani
Wonderful people, great customer service, and an excellent turnaround time! They did a great job fixing my chain, and I really appreciate the quality of the work. Highly recommend!
T C
Stephanie and Eddie were absolutely amazing! They were incredibly helpful, honest, communicative, and informative throughout the entire process. They were able to resize my fiancée’s engagement ring, and the turnaround time was impressively quick. The customer service and overall experience were excellent, and I already know that when it’s time to purchase my ring, It will be from Astra Jewelers! Thank you both again for making this such a great experience. I highly recommend Astra Jewelers!
Shanee Mitchell
Fantastic experience. Great work from a family-owned and entrepreneurial business, and exceedingly nice people. This is THE place to go, also supporting local Montclair business people!
Jonathan Roth

Read all our reviews on Google, rated 5.0

Recent work from the studio

Choosing the stone

The part that decides
everything after it

A radiant cut solitaire ring on a dark reflective surface

Natural or lab grown

Same mineral, same grading scale. Nobody can tell them apart by eye. What differs is how the stone was formed, one under the ground over roughly a billion years and one in a reactor over a few weeks, and what it costs.

Shown together at matching specification. Both come out on the desk in daylight with the certificates, so the comparison is yours. There is a longer version in our lab grown vs natural diamonds guide.

A loose gemstone held in tweezers under a lamp

Cut before clarity

Cut is what makes a diamond return light. A well cut stone one clarity grade lower usually looks brighter than a poorly cut stone with the better certificate. It also costs less.

Eye clean is the practical test. If an inclusion cannot be seen without magnification at normal distance, it is doing nothing to the way the ring looks on a hand.

Eternity bands set with sapphires, rubies and emeralds

Colored stones behave differently

Sapphire and ruby are hard enough for daily wear. Emerald is included by nature and usually oiled. Opal and pearl are softer again. Tanzanite is easier to chip than its price suggests.

Hardness decides the setting. A softer stone wants a bezel or a protected profile rather than raised prongs, which is a design decision made before the drawing, not after.

A ring sizer marked in millimeters beside a gauge

Millimeters, not carats

Two stones at the same carat weight can differ noticeably across the top, because weight can hide in a deep pavilion. The measurement that matters for how large a ring reads is the diameter.

The setting is cut to your stone. Seat depth, prong position and the gap under the stone are all built to the one you own, which is why the stone is chosen first.

Choosing the metal

How it will look
in ten years

Metal is usually picked on color in the showroom and regretted on wear. The differences are real and they are easy to explain, so here they are before you choose.

A white metal band set with small diamonds

Platinum

When platinum is scratched it displaces rather than sheds, so the metal moves around the mark instead of leaving. Prongs thin more slowly, which matters for the part of a ring that holds the stone.

It is denser and heavier on the hand, it develops a soft patina that some people prefer and others have polished off. It also costs more per gram.

Yellow gold bands stacked and reflecting warm light

14k and 18k gold

14k is harder. More alloy, more resistance to knocks and daily wear. The color reads slightly cooler.

18k is warmer and softer. Richer yellow and more precious metal by weight. Also more willing to pick up dings. Neither is the correct answer. It depends on whether the piece is worn every day or occasionally.

A ring being polished by hand at a bench

White gold and rhodium

White gold is yellow gold alloyed pale and then plated with rhodium to make it bright white. That plating wears, usually first on the back of the shank. Re-plating is a routine job every few years.

Nobody mentions this at the point of sale often enough. It is not a fault. It is maintenance. Worth knowing before you choose white over platinum. Our white gold vs platinum guide covers how each metal wears. The karat you pick, 14k or 18k, changes durability and color but not this. There is a longer explanation in our 14k vs 18k gold guide.

Setting tools and gravers arranged above a jeweler bench

Setting style and your hands

A high solitaire throws light and also catches on gloves, hair and car doors. A bezel or a lower profile trades some sparkle for a stone that survives a life spent using your hands.

Micro pave reads as delicate because it is. Small stones want checking periodically, which is ordinary jewelry repair work rather than a defect.

Inherited stones

Before we touch
your grandmother's ring

Resetting a family stone is the work people are most nervous about. They are right to ask questions first. Three things are worth knowing before anything is unset. And when the whole piece wants rethinking, not just the stone, our heirloom jewelry page covers redesign, restoration and keeping your own gold in the new piece.

A jeweler workbench laid out with hand tools

Damage hides under prongs

A chip at the girdle or a hairline running from an inclusion can sit invisible under a prong for fifty years. It is found by looking at the stone out of the setting, which is the first thing that happens rather than the last.

Antique rings with colored stones in raking light

Old cuts are not modern stones

Old European and transitional cuts often carry thin girdles. A thin girdle is more fragile at the moment of setting. That does not rule out a reset. It changes which settings are sensible.

A jeweler and a customer looking at rings together across the counter

Sometimes the answer is no

Occasionally a stone should stay where it is. Occasionally the old mount is worth keeping and restoring instead. You get told that plainly. An honest no costs a sale and saves a stone that cannot be replaced. There is a longer version in our guide to resetting an old diamond.

Before you come in

Custom design,
answered

How does custom jewelry design work?

It starts with a conversation at the studio, usually with stones on the desk rather than photographs on a screen. The stone is chosen first because the setting is built to its exact measurements. You then see a 3D rendering, then a printed model you can wear. Nothing is cast until you approve it.

Why is the stone chosen before the design?

Because a setting is built to a specific stone. Two diamonds of the same carat weight can differ by half a millimeter across. Prong position, seat depth and the gap under the stone are all cut to the one you actually own. Designing first and shopping for a stone to fit afterwards is how a setting ends up compromised.

Can you use a diamond or a stone I already have?

Yes. Resetting inherited stones is some of the most satisfying work in the studio. It starts with looking at the stone out of its old setting, because chips at the girdle and hairline damage hide under prongs for decades. You get an honest answer about what a stone can take before anything is unset.

Should I choose a natural or a lab grown diamond?

They are the same mineral graded on the same scale, so the two things that genuinely differ are how the stone was formed and what it costs. A natural diamond formed under the ground over roughly a billion years. A lab grown one is made in a reactor in a matter of weeks. At matching specification the lab grown stone costs less. We show both side by side in daylight with the certificates rather than steering you. The longer explanation is in our lab grown vs natural diamonds guide.

What metal should a custom ring be?

Platinum displaces rather than sheds metal when it wears, so prongs thin more slowly and a scratch pushes the surface around instead of removing it. 14k gold is harder than 18k and holds up better to daily knocks, while 18k is warmer in color and softer. White gold is yellow gold plated with rhodium, so it needs re-plating every few years to stay bright.

Which setting is right for how I use my hands?

A high solitaire catches light and also catches on gloves, hair and car doors. A bezel or a lower profile protects the stone and suits people who work with their hands. Micro pave looks delicate because it is. Small stones need checking periodically. That trade off is worth deciding before the piece is designed rather than after a stone is lost.

What happens if the printed model is not right?

That is exactly what the model is for. Proportions read differently on a hand than on a screen. Band width, stone height and the gap under the shank are the three that usually change. The design is adjusted and printed again before anything is cast.

Do you design pieces other than rings?

Yes. Pendants, earrings, bracelets and redesigns of jewelry that is no longer worn all go through the same process. Colored stones bring their own considerations, since emerald and opal are far softer than sapphire or ruby and want a setting that protects them.

How much does a custom piece cost?

It depends on the stone and the design. The stone is usually most of the cost, which is why we do not quote by phone or email. A number given without seeing the stones together would be a guess. Sit down with us instead, free of charge. The design comes back with its exact price for your approval before anything is made. Asking costs nothing.

Where are you located?

Astra Jewelers is at 250 Bellevue Ave, 2nd Floor, Montclair, NJ 07043, in Upper Montclair. Design appointments are Monday to Friday, 10:00am to 6:00pm, Saturday until 5:00pm. The studio serves Montclair, Glen Ridge, Bloomfield, Verona, Cedar Grove and the rest of Essex County.

Visit the studio

FIND ASTRA IN UPPER MONTCLAIR

We are a second-floor studio on Bellevue Avenue. Appointments get you undivided attention. Walk-ins are welcome during opening hours.

Address

250 Bellevue Ave, 2nd Floor, Montclair, NJ 07043

Hours: Mon-Fri: 10:00am-6:00pm, Sat: 10:00am-5:00pm

Get Directions +1-973-289-9290